I admit, this one had me at "peanut butter". I typically love toasted peanut butter and jelly sandwiches and figured: this has got to be good!! Since there was no original source (which we all know if you're following me it drives me crazy) So I assume it's like a grilled cheese sandwich.
I lightly buttered one side of two pieces of toast. Then I added peanut butter and a dab of jelly and put it on the griddle.
and cooked both sides until it was a nice golden brown
It was good. A little soggy in the centers despite my attempts of putting a light coat of butter on the toast. Was it worth the extra calories and time? Not really. I love melty peanut butter and I get the same effects (and crunchier toast) if I just use my toaster.